The register
86 payout requests between 20 May 2026 and 17 Nov 2026 ($23,320.03 requested, 80% split), read on the account's payout history and checked one by one on a public Ethereum RPC: receipt status OK and a USDC Transfer to …
Solana Funded (now Backed) leaves the ranking. Decided by Roya (owner) on 16 November 2026: the firm rebranded on 2 November 2026 and its offer changed; the score published until today described the previous offer and no longer has verifiable facts behind it. It will be scored again after a test under the new name. No other firm's score moves. WHAT CHANGES: the grid counts nine ranked firms instead of ten. Derived ranks: Carrot Funding 7th → 6th (64.1), Breakout 8th → 7th (62.0), HyperPNL 9th → 8th (56.3), GT Funded 10th → 9th (13.3); Propr (85.8), Hypernova (83.4), MyFundedPerps (77.7), Vest Markets (73.0) and Bungee Funded Perps (68.6) keep 1st to 5th. The withdrawn score was 64.2 (rules 62, payouts 75, survival 65, freedom 68, value 82, Roya's note 12, tested false); it is no longer shown as current anywhere, and the fiche keeps its address with a dated alert at the top. WHAT DOES NOT MOVE: no sub-score of any firm, no weight and no criterion. The entries below, and the totals and ranks they print, stay published as written: this file does not rewrite its own history.
Bungee Funded Perps: Roya's note 25 → 15 (total 78.6 → 68.6, Good → Fair, 3rd → 5th of 10)
Decided by Roya (owner) on 16 November 2026, after re-reading this note against the rule published the same day: Roya's note moves only after use or a re-read, in a dated revision, and no commercial agreement conditions it. The 25/25 had been published on 24 October 2026, the day the affiliate agreement with Bungee was signed. No objective sub-score moves.
MyFundedPerps: the Elite accounts without a daily loss limit now list at $99 / $194 / $482 / $965
Dropping the daily loss limit on an Elite account now costs about 95% more than keeping it on a 50K ($495 vs $965), against about 80% at our October read. The cheapest MyFundedPerps account is unchanged (Select 10K, $40 list). Prices published on this site for the Elite No DLL accounts were updated to this read.
Six cells moved against our 21 September read: Low $10K $115 to $110, $25K $280 to $275, $50K $495 to $500, $100K $999 to $1,000, $200K $1,850 to $1,950, and the $200K Medium went from TBD to $2,700. The $25K Low Risk now has one price on both of the firm's surfaces ($275), so the $5 discrepancy we published from 5 September is closed. The $200K Low Risk is $100 dearer in the document than in our old grid. Only the High risk tier is still unpriced. The fees above are the standard ones with the 80% split; the 90% option adds 20%. Prices published on this site for Hypernova were re-dated to this read.
Decided by Roya (owner) on 6 November 2026. One sub-score moves: PAYOUTS 72 → 82 (+10 points). THE FACTS, from our own payout registry (/payouts/, /api/payouts.json): between 27 and 31 October 2026 — five calendar days — MyFundedPerps paid our one Funded 50K (FP-93888846) eleven times, 6,775.08 USD credited to our Rise account, every Rise credit line read; those eleven credits left Rise in nine Arbitrum One transactions, each re-read by us on a public RPC and reconciled to the cent against the payouts it settles, 6,766.08 USDC attributed to the payouts after Rise's $1.00 fee per withdrawal (a non-trading Rise credit that left with the tenth payout is in no total). The 29 October entry rested on four payouts and two public transactions. WHAT STILL HOLDS PAYOUTS AT 82: the firm's docs publish no currency or network (USDC on Arbitrum is what we observed, not a published rule); the firm keeps no public payout registry, so our hashes prove our payouts and nobody else's; every request goes through a manual review; payouts are capped at $100,000 per trader for life; the brand has been public since September 2026; and eleven payouts on one funded account are still a sample of one account. 82 is level with Carrot (82), above Bungee (78, a public registry but nothing paid to us), below Propr (88) and Hypernova (96). TESTED stays true. RANK: fourth of eleven, unchanged — behind Bungee Funded Perps (78.6), ahead of Vest Markets (73.0). No other firm's score, weight or criterion moves; Hypernova's scores do not move (its last payout to us is dated 1 September 2026 and is shown as such on /prop-firms/). TOTAL: 72 × 0.20 + 82 × 0.20 + 58 × 0.15 + 78 × 0.10 + 74 × 0.10 + 23 = 77.7 — 75.7 → 77.7, Good unchanged; without Roya's note the five documentary criteria give 54.7 out of 75. CONFLICT OF INTEREST, said plainly: we are MyFundedPerps' affiliate and say so on every page; the 2.0 points come from the payouts criterion and rest on nine on-chain transactions anyone can check, and Roya's note, the one subjective criterion, does not move (23/25). The 29 October entry below (75.7), the 27 October entry (73.3) and the 17 October entry (70.3) were true on the grid of their day and stay as written: this file does not rewrite its history.
Author name shown as « Roya » throughout — at the owner's request; no fact, figure or score changes
Decided by Roya (owner) on 2 November 2026. Editorial note only: the owner's first name, which earlier entries of this log and some pages printed, is now shown as « Roya » throughout the site, at the owner's request. No fact, figure, date, weight, criterion, sub-score, total or rank changes, and no entry is otherwise rewritten.
Decided by Roya (owner) on 2 November 2026. WHAT CHANGES: `tested` goes from false to true for two firms, and nothing else. THE FACTS, ALREADY PUBLISHED AND DATED: Bungee Funded Perps — a Turbo $10K challenge bought on 22 October 2026 and traded the same day (11 fills, each charged 1.5 basis points as published); it failed on 23 October 2026 ("Maximum drawdown breached", final equity $9,687.19 against a $9,700 static floor — our trading error, the rule applied as written), and two Turbo $25K challenges were opened on 23 October 2026. Cashed — a first Standard $25,000 Evaluation issued to us free of charge by the firm on 13 October 2026 (one HYPE trade), then a Flex $440 Evaluation bought for $5.00 on 15 October 2026 (receipt published, read on 17 October 2026) and traded: one HYPE long settled at −$18.07 and the account failed on its 4% daily loss. WHY: the honesty rule of this grid defines `tested` as whether we bought and traded an evaluation, or only read the public documentation. Both firms meet that definition. The 17 October (Cashed) and 24 October (Bungee) entries kept `tested` false on the reading "until we buy and are paid" — that conflated `tested` with payouts. Whether a firm has paid us is graded by the payouts criterion, not by `tested`: neither firm has paid us anything, and both payouts sub-scores (Bungee 78, Cashed 58) already say so. WHAT DOES NOT MOVE: no score, no weight, no criterion and no rank. The 85-point desk-research cap was not binding on either firm — Bungee 78.6 and Cashed 71.8 are both below 85 — so lifting it changes no total: Bungee 78.6 (3rd of 11), Cashed 71.8 (6th of 11), every sub-score as written. The grid date stays 29 October 2026, because the grid date moves only when a score moves. Pages that showed "Docs only" for these two firms now show "Traded by us". The 17 October and 24 October entries stay published as written: this file does not rewrite its own history. We are the affiliate of both firms and say so on every page.
MyFundedPerps Payout History, read 1 Nov 2026: "$483.31 · Paid · Requested Oct 31, 2026 · Decided Oct 31, 2026 · Deducted $604.14" (604.14 × 0.80 = 483.31). Payout Certificate FP-C-BAHAGNFP, read on screen, dated Oct …
MyFundedPerps Payout History, read 1 Nov 2026: "$442.25 · Paid · Requested Oct 31, 2026 · Decided Oct 31, 2026 · Deducted $552.81" (552.81 × 0.80 = 442.25). Payout Certificate FP-C-RR9WVCCN, read on screen, dated Oct …
MyFundedPerps Payout History, read 1 Nov 2026: "$448.76 · Paid · Requested Oct 30, 2026 · Decided Oct 30, 2026 · Deducted $560.95" (560.95 × 0.80 = 448.76). Payout Certificate FP-C-554PHV9B, read on screen, dated Oct …
Decided by Roya (owner) on 29 October 2026. One sub-score moves: PAYOUTS 60 → 72 (+12 points). THE FACTS, VERIFIED: four payouts from MyFundedPerps on the same Funded 50K (Elite 3% DLL, FP-93888846) — $783.62, $509.73, $758.45 and $665.76, each exactly 80% of the amount deducted from the account, $2,717.56 in total, credited on Rise between 27 and 29 October 2026 — then withdrawn from Rise to USDC on Arbitrum One in two public transactions: 0x81183a…1ba6 (2,050.80 USDC, block time 28 October 2026 18:01:23 UTC, the first three payouts) and 0x7723ff…09cb (664.76 USDC, 28 October 2026 20:14:04 UTC, the fourth), 2,715.56 USDC net after $2.00 of Rise fees, received by our public wallet. Between the Rise credit of the fourth payout (03:06:03 Bangkok time) and the block of its withdrawal (03:14:04 Bangkok time), two timestamps we read, about 8 minutes passed; we did not read the time of the requests, so we state no delay from a request. WHAT JUSTIFIES +12: the 27 October entry held payouts at 60 first because there was no public hash; there are now two, of our own withdrawals, which anyone can open on Arbiscan; and one payout has become four on the same account, each paid and each exact to the cent. WHAT STILL HOLDS PAYOUTS AT 72: the currency and the network are not published by the firm's docs — USDC on Arbitrum is what we observed on our own withdrawals, not a published rule; the firm publishes no payout registry, so our hashes prove our payouts and nobody else's; every request goes through a manual review; payouts are capped at $100,000 per trader for life; on an Elite 50K a payout needs $500 of profit before the split (the app said so on 29 October 2026); the brand has been public since September 2026; and four payouts on one funded account are still a sample of one account. Solana Funded (75), Bungee (78), which publishes a registry with hashes, and Carrot (82) stay above. TESTED stays true. RANK: fourth of eleven, unchanged — behind Bungee Funded Perps (78.6), ahead of Vest Markets (73.0). No other firm's score, weight or criterion moves. TOTAL: 72 × 0.20 + 72 × 0.20 + 58 × 0.15 + 78 × 0.10 + 74 × 0.10 + 23 = 75.7 — 73.3 → 75.7, Good unchanged. CONFLICT OF INTEREST, said plainly: we are MyFundedPerps' affiliate and say so on every page; the 2.4 points gained come from the payouts criterion and rest on two on-chain transactions anyone can check, and Roya's note, the one subjective criterion, does not move (23/25). The 27 October entry below (73.3) and the 17 October entry (70.3) were true on the grid of their day and stay as written: this file does not rewrite its history.
Requested on our Funded 50K (Elite 3% DLL, FP-93888846) — the MyFundedPerps Payout History shows "$665.76 · Certificate · Paid · Requested Oct 29, 2026 · Decided Oct 29, 2026 · Deducted $832.20" (832.20 × 0.80 = 665.7…
Requested on our Funded 50K (Elite 3% DLL, FP-93888846) — the MyFundedPerps Payout History shows "$1,083.50 · Certificate · Paid · Requested Oct 29, 2026 · Decided Oct 29, 2026 · Deducted $1,354.38" (1,354.38 × 0.80 =…
Requested on our Funded 50K (Elite 3% DLL, FP-93888846) — the MyFundedPerps Payout History shows "$552.96 · Certificate · Paid · Requested Oct 29, 2026 · Decided Oct 29, 2026 · Deducted $691.20" (691.20 × 0.80 = 552.9…
MyFundedPerps Payout History, read 1 Nov 2026: "$508.36 · Paid · Requested Oct 29, 2026 · Decided Oct 29, 2026 · Deducted $635.45" (635.45 × 0.80 = 508.36). Payout Certificate FP-C-YJMVS3ZA, read on screen, dated Oct …
MyFundedPerps Payout History, read 1 Nov 2026: "$538.38 · Paid · Requested Oct 29, 2026 · Decided Oct 29, 2026 · Deducted $672.98" (672.98 × 0.80 = 538.38). Payout Certificate FP-C-Z6DA33CR, read on screen, dated Oct …
Requested on our Funded 50K (Elite 3% DLL, FP-93888846) — the MyFundedPerps Payout History shows "$758.45 · Certificate · Paid · Requested Oct 28, 2026 · Decided Oct 28, 2026 · Deducted $948.06" (948.06 × 0.80 = 758.4…
Decided by Roya (owner) on 27 October 2026. Two things move, both about the same fact. PAYOUTS 45 → 60 (+15 points) and tested false → true. THE FACT, VERIFIED: our first payout from MyFundedPerps, $783.62 (80% of $979.53 of cycle profit) on our Funded 50K (Elite 3% DLL, FP-93888846), was requested and paid the same calendar day through Rise. We read it on 27 October 2026 in Rise Pay → Payments: one line, "My Funded Perpetuals · Payout - Funded Trader · $783.62 · Complete · Pay Date Oct 27, 2026"; MyFundedPerps also issued a Payout Certificate (FP-C-MNKN5CNG, dated 26 October, which is the firm's own document and not our proof — the Rise line is). WHAT JUSTIFIES +15: the payout was paid, it was fast (the request and the Pay Date fall on the same calendar day, under 24 hours; the Payout Terms in the app say reviews normally complete within two business days) and the amount is exact (80% of the cycle profit the modal showed, to the cent). The 45 of 16 October was set while nothing had been received; that is no longer true. WHAT STILL HOLDS PAYOUTS AT 60: there is no public hash — what we hold is a USD balance on Rise, and the withdrawal to USDC on Arbitrum is not executed; the docs do not publish the currency or the network; there is no public payout registry; payouts are capped at $100,000 cumulated per trader for life; every request goes through a manual review during which trading is locked; and one payout on one account is a sample of one. Bungee, which publishes a registry with hashes we read on-chain, stays at 78. TESTED false → true because a payout was actually received on our own account: the 85-point desk-research cap is lifted. It did not bind either way (73.3 is below 85). NEW RANK: fourth of eleven (sixth since Bungee joined the grid on 24 October 2026, behind Vest Markets and Cashed), behind Bungee Funded Perps (78.6) and ahead of Vest Markets (73.0) and Cashed (71.8). No other firm's score, weight or criterion moves. TOTAL: 72 × 0.20 + 60 × 0.20 + 58 × 0.15 + 78 × 0.10 + 74 × 0.10 + 23 = 73.3 — 70.3 → 73.3, Good unchanged, sixth → fourth. CONFLICT OF INTEREST, said plainly: we are MyFundedPerps' affiliate and say so on every page; the 3 points gained come from the payouts criterion, which rests on a fact anyone can check against our published Rise screenshots, and Roya's note, the one subjective criterion, does not move (23/25). The 17 October entry below (70.3, fifth) was true on the grid of that day and stays as written: this file does not rewrite its history.
Requested on our Funded 50K (Elite 3% DLL, FP-93888846) on Oct 27, 2026: $783.62, 80% of $979.53 of cycle profit (979.53 × 0.80 = 783.624). Rise Pay → Payments (Accounts Receivable) shows one line from "My Funded Perp…
Requested on our Funded 50K (Elite 3% DLL, FP-93888846) — the MyFundedPerps Payout History shows "$509.73 · Certificate · Paid · Requested Oct 27, 2026 · Decided Oct 27, 2026 · Deducted $637.16" (637.16 × 0.80 = 509.7…
An eleventh firm, scored on 22 October 2026 and published on 24 October 2026 (decided by Roya, owner). Sources read on 22 October 2026: the rulebook and the FAQ loaded by the site from GitHub (SocketDotTech/rulebook v0.4 of 3 October 2026, with a v0.5 draft pushed at 12:58 UTC and already live on the in-app Rules page at 13:29 UTC; bungee-funded-perps-faq, commit of 15 October 2026), the public API (products, markets, trust-stats, payouts, leaderboard), Socket's Terms of Use (2 March 2026), three payout transactions read on a Base RPC, and Roya's own account; re-read on 24 October 2026. tested is false: a Turbo $10K challenge was bought on 22 October 2026 (list price $45; the price paid was not read) and traded with fills charged 1.5 basis points taker, as published; it FAILED on 23 October 2026 — 'Maximum drawdown breached', final equity $9,687.19 against a static floor of $9,700 after a CL short we held against us. That is our trading error; the rule applied exactly as written, and the same screen showed the daily floor recomputed at the 00:00 UTC reset ($9,668.04, 97% of the settled balance) while the overall floor stayed at $9,700. Two Turbo $25K were opened on 23 October 2026; nothing has been received; the 85-point desk cap applies and does not bind. WHAT BUNGEE FUNDED PERPS IS. The prop program of Bungee, the bridge and swap product operated, per the only legal document found, by Socket Technologies Limited (British Virgin Islands); those Terms describe a cross-chain bridging platform with no financial services and never mention Funded Perps, a challenge or a payout, and the 'Bungee Funded Perps Terms' the rulebook and the FAQ cite have no URL anywhere. One-step challenges on three tracks (Classic 10% target, 3% daily, 6% static drawdown; Pro 12/3/5; Turbo 9/3/3), $45 (Turbo 10K) to $900 (Classic 100K), paid in USDC on Arbitrum, Base, BNB Chain, Ethereum or Solana; $110,000 of combined active account size; 80/20 split; a referral code required for the first purchase. The FAQ states that challenge and funded trading both use simulated accounts and that Bungee may simulate, hedge or execute externally at its discretion; the venue is never named (Hyperliquid is implicit). Payouts in USDC on Base from a Gnosis Safe with a 1-of-4 threshold. RULES 70: a numbered rulebook on a public, versioned GitHub repository with a changelog, prices in the app and the API, floors shown in dollars on the account, a daily loss defined as 3% of the settled balance at 00:00 UTC checked on live equity, a static drawdown on the starting balance, no time limit, no minimum days, no consistency rule. Held back by the absence of any Terms, privacy or refund policy for the product; a rulebook in transition on the day of reading; a payout rule that differs between the rulebook (per account, rolling 24 h, $50 minimum) and the FAQ (per user, shared, no fixed minimum, rejection final); a landing still showing 'up to 5x' and '$100k' where the API and the rulebook say 20x and $110,000; a products API carrying fee_bps 3.5 against 1.5 everywhere else (our fills settled it at 1.5); SILVER at 4x in the API and 5x on the Assets page; an 'Active days / 30' counter on an account whose rules say no time limit. PAYOUTS 78: a public payout registry of 210 entries (1 to 22 October 2026, 156,166.73 USDC to 46 traders, hash, amount, chain and time per entry), of which we read three on the chain — 5,936.21, 1,591.23 and 827.80 USDC on 22 October 2026 at 11:46–11:47 UTC, sent by the Safe 0xf0d112ca…72c0, amounts and timestamps identical to the API; a median of about 12.6 hours between request and payment over the 210, against a stated target of one business day; $50 minimum, 80% split, no lifetime cap. Against: nothing paid to us; the rule contradicted across documents; a payer with a 1-of-4 signing threshold; payout requests denied at Bungee's discretion when a prohibited pattern (bots, HFT, scalping) is confirmed. SURVIVAL 64: a parent product running bridging infrastructure since 2022 with figures it publishes about itself (bridge figures, unconfirmed by any press we found), a named BVI entity, an X account created in 2022, a payer Safe whose balance is readable (27,775.53 USDC on 22 October 2026 at 13:17 UTC — a working float, not a reserve). Against: a prop program four weeks old (announced on X on 24 September 2026, first payout 1 October), no press, no community review, a Trustpilot profile at 3.2/5 on one unrelated 2025 review, no proof of reserve, four rulebook versions in three weeks. FREEDOM 62: 30 markets in four asset classes, crypto 24/7, news and weekend trading allowed, no consistency rule, BTC and gold at 10x, S&P 500 and Nasdaq 100 at 20x. Held back by the prohibition of bots, APIs, HFT and scalping (judged by Bungee, no fixed minimum hold), copy trading banned, isolated margin only, no hedge mode, leverage fixed and not adjustable, per-market notional caps, a web terminal only. VALUE 82: $45 for a $10,000 Turbo (0.45% of account size) and $360 for a $100,000 Turbo (0.36%), the lowest price per dollar of account on this grid; 1.5 basis points per fill, maker and taker, verified on our own fills; no monthly fee. Held back by hourly funding that is never negative and never credited, no 90% option, no refund policy, a hard breach with no reset, and a 3% static drawdown on the cheapest track. ROYA'S NOTE: 25 out of 25 — Roya's own rating, in Roya's words, in French, « hyper transparents »; it is an opinion and is published as one. TOTAL: 70 × 0.20 + 78 × 0.20 + 64 × 0.15 + 62 × 0.10 + 82 × 0.10 + 25 = 78.6, 'Good' — third of eleven, behind Propr (85.8) and Hypernova (83.4), ahead of Vest Markets (73.0). CONFLICT OF INTEREST, said plainly: 25 of the 78.6 points are Roya's note, the one subjective criterion; without it the five documentary criteria give 53.6 out of 75 — the note is shown on its own line so that anyone can subtract it. No other firm's score, weight or criterion moves. We are Bungee's affiliate and say so on every page: our link carries the code ROYA (10% off every challenge, read on our referral dashboard and on Bungee's public code-preview endpoint on 24 October 2026); our commission is not published.
Propr: §17 rewritten to carry the $200,000 evaluation cap — no changelog entry, no version bump
The cap announced on X on 19 October is now in the contract a buyer agrees to — §01 says “By purchasing an evaluation, you agree to these rules in full”. A trader may hold at most $200,000 of active evaluations at one time. What a buyer still cannot do is see that the text moved: the document is versioned and carries a changelog that records far smaller changes, including the July entry raising the aggregate funded limit from $200,000 to $300,000, and neither was updated here.
Propr: challenge AUM capped at $200,000 per trader, announced on X and absent from the rulebook
A trader may now hold at most $200,000 of active evaluations at one time — one $200K challenge, or two $100K, and nothing more until one resolves. It does not touch challenges already open (the firm says so explicitly) and it does not change the $300,000 funded ceiling. It is a tightening of how many evaluation fees one person can pay at once, announced the same day the founder posted that revenue had passed $5m, and in a month with no promo code since 2MPAID expired on 30 September. Until §17 is re-versioned, treat the cap as an announced rule and the rulebook as the document that has not caught up — the same page states that purchasing an evaluation means agreeing to those rules in full.
For a buyer, nothing on the firm's own site reflects this: the split shown at purchase is still 80%, so the add-on is only findable through the X post and the Discord. Nothing published says what the add-on costs after 26 October, whether it becomes a paid option or disappears, or whether an account that takes it keeps 90% for life — the one number that decides whether this is a discount or a new standard. We have NOT moved the 80% we publish for Hypernova, because 80% is what the firm's buying surface says. This is the second standing gap of its kind: “Max leverage 5x” is still printed on all three tiers six days after the firm announced 10x on BTC, ETH and SOL on 14 October.
Decided by Roya (owner) on 17 October 2026. One sub-score moves, and it is the subjective one: Roya's note, 18 → 23 out of 25 — Roya's own rating after using our Elite 50K Challenge (in Roya's words, in French: « vraiment incroyable d'utilisation, très bon produit »). It is an opinion and is published as one. NO OBJECTIVE SUB-SCORE MOVES: rules 72, payouts 45, survival 58, freedom 78, value 74. Nothing has been paid to us and the receipt of the 50K is still unpublished, so tested stays false; the 85-point desk cap does not bind at 70.3. A DATED FACT, NOT A SCORE INPUT: read at checkout on 17 October 2026 (~05:45 UTC), the firm's public code PERPS now takes 25% off ("Discount (25%)", Elite 5K $49 → $36), the same rate as our code ROYA ("25% Off · No usage limit" on our affiliate dashboard the same day). The 16 October entry below says the firm's homepage showed 30% off with a public code that day; that was true on 16 October and stays as written, and the current verdict now says what the checkout showed on 17 October. TOTAL: 72 × 0.20 + 45 × 0.20 + 58 × 0.15 + 78 × 0.10 + 74 × 0.10 + 23 = 70.3 — 65.3 → 70.3, Fair → Good, still fifth of ten, behind Cashed (71.8) and ahead of Solana Funded (64.2). The whole movement is Roya's note: we are MyFundedPerps' affiliate and say so on every page, and a subjective point given by an affiliate is exactly what a reader should weigh with care — which is why the note is printed on its own line for every firm and anyone can subtract it. The 65.3 in the entry below was true on the grid of 16 October and stays as written: this file does not rewrite its history.
A tenth firm, scored on 16 October 2026 on the six-criterion grid adopted the same day, from its published documents (documentation, Terms, Refund Policy, Privacy Policy, Disclaimer and public API, all read on 15 October 2026) and from one reading of our own account. tested is false and the 85-point desk cap applies (not binding): Roya bought an Elite 50K Challenge on 15 October 2026 — the receipt is not yet published — and we have received nothing. WHAT MYFUNDEDPERPS IS. A crypto-perpetuals prop firm operated by Funding Perpetuals Holdings, Inc., a Delaware corporation, marketed as "from the team behind My Funded Futures" while its own Refund and Privacy policies call it "a company separate from MyFunded Futures, LLC"; the paid-out figures on its homepage belong to the futures firm and count for nothing here. Every account is simulated: the docs say nothing in the trading workspace places an order on an external exchange, the public markets API attributes 113 of 135 markets to Binance data, 15 to Hyperliquid, 6 to Veranta and 1 to Ostium, and the Terms say profit-split payments "are paid from the Company's own funds, not from real trading gains". It is scored as a centralised firm with simulated accounts and stays out of the on-chain and USDC rankings. RULES 72: about a hundred documentation pages, readable before payment, with numbers a buyer can compute — 1-Step only, static drawdown (Select 3%, Prime 5%, Signature 6%, Elite 5%), an optional 3% daily loss on Elite, no time limit, no minimum days, no consistency rule, active challenges governed by the rules in force at activation; our own account shows its floor exactly where the docs put it ($47,500, "fixed"). Held back by contradictions between the firm's own documents, all read on 15 October 2026: the Terms say profit payouts are processed on a weekly schedule while the docs allow a request every New York day (on demand on Elite); the docs measure the profit target on equity, an earlier post on the firm's own blog on realised balance; the docs carry a $100,000 lifetime payout cap the same blog said did not exist; the Terms cap purchases at 10 accounts per 24 hours where the docs say there is no limit; the Terms forbid bots used to gain a latency advantage while the docs sell an API, an MCP server and a CLI; four different lists of execution venues; and the 106 answers of the public FAQ are not served in the page's HTML. More of these than Cashed (75) or Vest Markets (80). PAYOUTS 45: an 80/20 split (90/10 as a paid option), requests from 1% of the account size on Elite ($500 gross on a 50K), paid through Rise after a manual review during which trading is locked; the currency, the network and the delay are not published, requests can be paused, payouts are capped at $100,000 cumulated per trader for life, and there is no public payout registry, hash or address. We have received nothing. Below Breakout (55) and Cashed (58), which at least name their payout asset and rail. SURVIVAL 58: the brand has been public for about a month (payout requests opened on 11 September 2026; the Disclaimer's effective date is September 2026), the Delaware entity could not be found in a public registry, its press coverage is paid releases, and a simulated product has no reserve to read. In its favour: a parent brand whose published track record starts in 2023 and named executives in its 3 September 2026 release — operational backing rather than a legal guarantee, since the company is separate — a Trustpilot profile at 4.4/5 on 58 reviews (page as cached around 28 September 2026, including five near-identical one-star reviews the firm calls a coordinated campaign), and DNS and HTTP responding. Above Cashed (45), below Solana Funded (65). FREEDOM 78: a REST and WebSocket API, an MCP server and a CLI, about 134 markets across crypto, stocks, indices, FX and commodities, news trading unrestricted during the evaluation, crypto held over weekends, Elite leverage raised to 40x on NAS100 and SP500. Held back by 2x to 3x on most altcoins (XPL 2x), restricted windows around high-impact news on funded accounts, 23/5 markets closed automatically before the weekend, VPNs and proxies prohibited, fourteen named prohibited strategies, no hedge mode, per-market exposure caps, and a bot clause in the Terms narrower than the docs. VALUE 74: Elite 50K at $495 with the 3% daily loss (0.99% of account size) or $889 without it, Elite 5K from $49, no recurring fee, a 0.03% commission per crypto fill — verified to the cent on our one fill, $14.91 on $49,702.57 — a 48-hour refund if the account is untouched (minus $25), and 25% off with code ROYA, while the firm's homepage showed 30% off with a public code the same day. Held back by an hourly swap on every open position (0.03% a day on crypto), the 90/10 split costing about 20% more, no reset (a failed account is bought again), the $500 Elite payout floor and the $100,000 lifetime cap; dearer per dollar of account than Vest Markets (0.8%) or Cashed (0.83%). ROYA'S NOTE: 18 out of 25, Roya's own rating. TOTAL: 72 × 0.20 + 45 × 0.20 + 58 × 0.15 + 78 × 0.10 + 74 × 0.10 + 18 = 65.3, "Fair", fifth of ten — below Cashed (69.4), above Solana Funded (64.2). No other firm's score, weight or criterion moves. We are MyFundedPerps' affiliate and say so on every page; the firm did not see this grid before publication.
A CHANGE OF METHOD, decided by Roya (owner) on 16 October 2026 — not a re-reading of any firm. WHAT IS ADDED: a sixth criterion, Roya's note, written out of 25 and counted as 25 of the 100 points. It is the one subjective criterion in the grid: Roya's own rating after using the firm — interface, execution, support, how it feels — where the five others are documentary or measured. On a firm we have not traded with our own money (Solana Funded, Breakout and GT Funded, and Cashed, whose account was issued to us free) it is an opinion formed without a paid account. It is labelled as an opinion everywhere the method is explained, it is published firm by firm like every sub-score, and anyone can subtract it from a total. WHAT MOVES: the weights only. Rules 25 → 20, payouts 25 → 20, survival 20 → 15, trading freedom 15 → 10, cost and value 15 → 10, Roya's note 25 (new); the sum stays 100. No sub-score on the five existing criteria changes. Total = the sum of sub-score × weight / 100 over the five criteria scored out of 100, plus Roya's note as written (out of 25, it counts point for point), rounded to one decimal; the 85-point cap on firms we have not traded is unchanged, applied after the sum, and binds on no firm today. ROYA'S NOTES, OUT OF 25: Propr 20, Cashed 20, Hypernova 19, Vest Markets 16, Solana Funded 12, Breakout 10, Carrot Funding 9, HyperPNL 8, GT Funded 0. TOTALS, OLD → NEW (RANK): Propr 87.7 → 85.8 (1st → 1st); Hypernova 85.7 → 83.4 (2nd → 2nd); Vest Markets 76.1 → 73.0 (3rd → 3rd); Cashed 66.3 → 69.4 (7th → 4th); Solana Funded 69.8 → 64.2 (5th → 5th); Carrot Funding 73.2 → 64.1 (4th → 6th); Breakout 69.5 → 62.0 (6th → 7th); HyperPNL 64.5 → 56.3 (8th → 8th); GT Funded 18.3 → 13.3 (9th → 9th). Two labels change with the totals: Hypernova Excellent → Good, Carrot Funding Good → Fair. Cashed, which we have not traded with our own money, now ranks above Carrot Funding, which we bought and traded: that is the weight of Roya's note (20 against 9), it is the owner's decision, and it is published as such. WHAT DOES NOT CHANGE: the history. Every total in the entries below and in dated articles across the site was true on the grid of its date and stays as written; this file does not rewrite its own history. We are affiliates of Propr, Hypernova, Vest Markets, Cashed and Carrot Funding and say so on every page; Roya's note is the criterion where that conflict of interest is hardest to rule out, which is exactly why it is shown on its own line for every firm.
One sub-score, one reason. On 9 October 2026 at 08:10:52 UTC we claimed $14.078881 from our $5,000 Vest Capital funded account — "You Will Receive $11.263104", exactly 80%. The account was closed by its 3% daily loss limit at 12:43 UTC the same day; the claim was paid anyway, "Completed" on the Primary Account on 10 October at 08:01:16 UTC (23 h 50), as the docs' "Irrevocable once initiated" says. We requested the USDC withdrawal at 08:25:40 UTC on Arbitrum One; the app said "Funds arrive 24h after each request" where the docs say instant under $50,000 per rolling 24 h. On 11 October 2026 at 08:19:32 UTC (block 513,763,604, status success, read on a public Arbitrum RPC) 11.263104 native USDC landed on our wallet — tx 0x806410512eb6de86dc1e5ed9b5e6ee37761e0f042c5bec3ace2db5ea16f027d9 — sent by 0xb2f86eae1197032fa85389cc6c0f3b06b58dd1ea, a contract that is Vest's withdrawal address and that Vest does not publish; we know it only from this transaction. Reconciliation: 14.078881 × 0.80 = 11.263104, to the millionth. Measured: 23 h 54 from request to chain, about 48 h from claim to wallet. No KYC was requested at any step. WHY +8: a payout received and reconciled to the cent on a public ledger, paid despite the closure of the account, and one Vest sending address now observable. WHY NOT MORE: Vest publishes no payout address, no contract and no reserve, so nobody can check a Vest payout from outside; the real withdrawal took about 24 h against "instant"; and it is a sample of one. That keeps it below Carrot (82), far below Propr (88) and Hypernova (96). Rules 80, survival 76, freedom 72 and value 84 do not move. Total 74.1 → 76.1, still "Good". We are Vest's affiliate and say so on every page; the firm did not see this revision before publication.
Claimed on our $5,000 funded account on 9 Oct 2026 at 08:10:52 UTC: $14.078881 gross, "You Will Receive $11.263104" — 80% exactly (14.078881 × 0.80 = 11.263104). Credited to the Primary Account on 10 Oct at 08:01:16 U…
An eighth firm, scored on a paid account rather than desk research: we bought a Silver $5,000 1-Step evaluation (10% target, 3% daily loss limit, 80/20 split) on 8 October 2026 for $38.00 — $40 list, −5% with a discount code pre-filled in our session (not ours; ROYA gives the same discount, checked on 9 October), Stripe receipt 1552-9436 — and Roya traded it on 9 October (SKHY long 5x, NVDA long 25x). The account is in evaluation and no payout has been requested; nothing below is inferred from a payout we never took. WHAT VEST IS. Vest Markets is a centralised perpetuals exchange (Vest Labs on screen; the program is contracted by Vest Exchange Inc., Panama) whose Prop Trading Terms of 6 October 2026 state that "All Accounts, including Instant Funded Accounts, are simulated" and that fees buy access to the program, not assets — while its marketing sells "real trading capital". Payouts are an internal credit ("Claim Profit", 24h stated, no cap on amount or frequency) followed by a USDC withdrawal on Base or Arbitrum One. No payout address, no distribution contract and no readable reserve are published, so nothing about a Vest payout can be reconciled against a public ledger the way Propr's distributor or Hypernova's vault can. It is scored as a centralised firm with simulated accounts that pays in USDC, and it stays out of the on-chain tiers. RULES 80: the whole product is priced and written before payment — the 36-configuration 1-Step matrix, the daily-loss formula (3% or 4% of the reset balance, reset 20:00 ET, unrealised P&L included), a static 6% maximum drawdown, no consistency rule, no time limit, no minimum days. Held back by four public contradictions read on 9 October 2026: a 3-day refund window in the docs against 28 days in the Terms and the FAQ; "simulated" in the Terms against "real capital" in the marketing; a hero promising 90% while the three default cards show 80% (the 90% split is a paid option, +20% on price); a breach at exactly the floor in the FAQ ("touches or drops below") against "equality alone does not breach a limit" in the docs. (Vest Labs Inc. in the footer and Vest Exchange Inc. in the Terms are two related companies — the program disclosure calls Vest Exchange an affiliated venue — not a contradiction.) The Terms are amendable without notice and there is no public changelog. PAYOUTS 62: claim within 24h as stated, no cap on amount or frequency, then an on-chain USDC withdrawal — but the claim is an internal credit we cannot verify, nothing is published to check it against, and we have received nothing ourselves. Above HyperPNL (60) and Breakout (55), far below Propr (88) and Hypernova (96). SURVIVAL 76: a $13M seed round led by Portal Ventures, announced on 7 October 2026 by Fortune, named backers, an OtterSec audit of the exchange contracts, and incident reports the firm publishes itself (erroneous liquidations on 15 April 2026 affecting about 10% of active accounts; further incidents on 8 and 30 June 2026 — all on the earlier trade.vestmarkets.com platform, with affected accounts reinstated or compensated per Vest); DNS and HTTP respond. Held back by a simulated program with no on-chain solvency to read, a Panamanian contracting entity distinct from the one shown on screen, and a recent funded program. FREEDOM 72: the only cross-asset firm in the table — stocks, indices, commodities, FX, crypto — with news, scalping and weekend trading allowed and up to 50x on funded accounts (NQ/RTY; ES 75x), though 74 of the 88 markets in the docs' leverage table are capped at 5x; held back by the absence of any API on funded accounts, the exclusion of XRP and HYPE, positions locked across the weekend close on everything but crypto, and BTC/ETH capped at 15x. VALUE 84: $40 for $5,000 (0.8%), a 2-Step from $15, Instant from $10, splits of 80, 90 or 95%, 0.01% taker fees, a 28-day refund if the account is untouched (Terms), −5% with ROYA; held back by the $25,000 ceiling per account and the 10-live-account cap, the 90% split being a paid option, and a daily limit that counts unrealised P&L. Total 74.1, "Good": above Carrot (73.2) on value and on how plainly the rules are written, well below Hypernova (85.7) and Propr (87.7) because none of it verifies on a chain. No other firm's score, weight or criterion moves. We are Vest's affiliate and say so on every page; the firm did not see this grid before publication.
Propr survival 77 → 82 (total 86.7 → 87.7) — a reserve you can read before it pays
The markdown that held Propr's survival line at 77 since 26 August 2026 read: the Payout Distributor holds ~no balance, payouts are funded per transaction, so there is still no reserve you can read before it pays. That fact expired on 3 October 2026 at 11:15 UTC, when Propr published a Proof of Reserve across three public wallets (cold reserve and hot reserve on Ethereum, margin on Hyperliquid) and listed the cold-storage address in its Address Directory. We did not take the card's $1.03M on trust. On 4 October 2026 at 02:43 UTC (Ethereum block 26,116,075 via a public RPC, Hyperliquid info API) we read 499,999.00 USDC on the cold wallet 0xeaf6…8c3f — funded by four transfers of 999, 99,000, 200,000 and 200,000 USDC on 2 and 3 October, hashes published in our article — 34,573.14 USDC on the hot wallet 0x0353…bB1d, and 491,090.82 USDC spot on the Hyperliquid wallet 0x3b9e…c503: 1,025,662.96 USDC of stablecoin, plus 76,715.38 of perps account value under open hedges. A readable reserve is exactly what survival has rewarded since 12 August 2026, so the markdown moves: 77 → 82 (+5 × 20% = +1.0; 86.7 → 87.7). Why not more: the cold reserve is one day old, both Ethereum wallets are plain externally-owned addresses with no multisig or custody disclosure, and about half of the stack is Hyperliquid margin that backs open hedges and moves with them (191,439 of perps account value on 2 October, 76,715 on 4 October). Hypernova's survival stays at 80: its reserve is smaller today (452,283.59 USDC on 3 October) but has been readable for two months inside the vault its payouts draw from. Nothing else moves: payouts stay at 88 (this is solvency, not payment), the unannounced-price-rise markdown under rules stays. The firm did not ask for this; we are its affiliate and say so on every page. The chain read is the input, the announcement was only the prompt.
Four of the ten tracked sites re-read in full on 26 September 2026; the other six covered by that morning's automated DNS/HTTP sweep. GT Funded: www.gtfunded.xyz answers 307 → 200 and its page metadata now advertises …
Hypernova reserve down $169,194.50 in four days: $958,399.39 (15 Sep) → $789,204.89 (19 Sep)
Daily 03:00 UTC on-chain readings of Hypernova's payout reserve on Arbitrum (vault + reserve wallet): $958,399.39 on 15 September, $925,592.74 on 16 September, $870,858.82 on 17 September, $849,504.79 on 18 September,…
We bought the largest product Propr sells — the Diamond 1-Step Classic, $200,000 — on 2026-09-14, passed it on 2026-09-18 and took two payouts the same day. Requested $444.23 and $286.11; received 355.3822 and 228.887…
Two practical consequences. First, your catalogue is filtered twice: by what Hyperliquid lists, and then by Propr's own liquidity floor of $1M open interest and $500K daily volume — the rulebook only tells you about the first filter. Second, and this is the one that costs money: if a market you hold falls below that floor, it goes reduce-only, meaning you can close and only close — no adding, no reversing, no re-entering after you exit. On a funded account whose drawdown is measured against a balance you have to defend, that removes your ability to manage the position on your own terms, and it is triggered by the market's liquidity rather than by anything you did. None of this is unreasonable risk management — a dried-up perp is a genuine hazard, and $1M/$500K is not a harsh bar. The finding is narrower: a criterion disclosed in a reply to one trader is not a published rule, it can move tomorrow with no changelog, and anyone who bought a challenge last week has no way of knowing it exists. If you run a Propr funded account on a small-cap perp, watch open interest and 24h volume on Hyperliquid itself, where both are public per market.
From 13 to 15 September 2026 our automated daily sweep recorded 'dns: no-record' for every tracked domain, live firms included, and that reading reached registry.json and the register table. It was false: the sites we…
Hypernova reserve read: $977,923.42
Automated chain read (block 504954779). Wallet unchanged to the cent; vault −$885.23 in 12 hours (payout flow — the stats page lists a $562 payout dated 13 Sep). Stats page displayed $988,363 the same morning, +$10.4K over the chain. Lifetime payouts counter $822,890, up $91.5K since 7 Sep while the vault fell only $5.0K over the week: ~$86K entered the vault from an untraced source in the window.
Hypernova reserve read: $978,808.66
First automated chain read (block 504778439). Reserve wallet net +340,000.00 USDC since 7 Sep (to within 0.2 cent), vault −$4,145. The firm's 11 Sep post said '$440,000 added' and 'back to $1,000,000': corroborated in direction, not in amount — the wallet's NET movement is $100K short of the first figure and the total is $21.2K short of the second. Whether ~$100K also left the wallet in the same window is untraced.
On 10 September 2026 we published one thing as untested and refused to infer it: what Carrot's balance-based Objectives counter displays while a position floats at a LOSS, which is the case that actually matters. The account answered the question the same evening by dying, and the dashboard read on 11 September carries the whole sequence. Two BTC/USD longs at 5x, no stop loss, about $24,930 of notional on a $5,000 account, held overnight. BTC moved roughly 1.1% against them. Both were force-closed at 19:30:42 at the same price, 77,420.0, and the day closed 4 trades at -$288.78: $5,000 to $4,711.22. THE CHART IS THE PROOF. BALANCE stayed flat at 4,986.169 the entire way down while EQUITY fell 5,054.693 -> 5,018.706 -> 4,922.21 -> 4,917.752 -> 4,879.217 -> 4,839.727 -> 4,836.86, then dropped vertically to 4,711.225 on the forced close. The realized balance never moved more than $13.83, so it is the equity that crossed the 4,750 daily floor and the floating loss that took the account — exactly as §05 and the public FAQ state, and exactly against the §24 cheatsheet cell reading "Balance-based (does not include floating P&L)". Our 10 September reading is confirmed end to end, and that cheatsheet cell remains the one wrong line in the documentation. TWO FURTHER FACTS, BOTH OBSERVED. The daily floor sat at 4,750 and the account settled at 4,711.22, i.e. $38.78 THROUGH the stated limit: the forced close slipped past it. And the Max loss counter stopped at $288.78 of $500.00, so $211.22 of the total drawdown budget was never used — on this product it is the DAILY limit that ends accounts, not the total one. ONE FIGURE IS DERIVED RATHER THAN PHOTOGRAPHED and is labelled as such, because we have no capture of the counter mid-drawdown: since the counter reads 5,000 minus the balance, and the balance was frozen at 4,986.169, it would have displayed $13.83 of $500.00 while equity sat at 4,836.86, roughly $87 from death. It is arithmetic, not an observation, and it is published as arithmetic. ATTRIBUTION, because it decides how this is written: the breach is OURS, not the firm's. No stop loss was set and 5x of notional was carried overnight. The engine enforced a published rule correctly and the interface showed the floor in absolute dollars on screen the whole time. Nothing here is scored against Carrot, and the score does not move: 73.2/100, on the grid of 10 September 2026. The rules criterion was already raised to 78 that day on exactly this reading; a first-hand confirmation of a finding already priced in moves no criterion, and this grid does not re-score a firm for having been right twice. What IS reported, in figures and without adjectives, is the screen that follows a breach: "Challenge Failed", then 15% off a new challenge behind a countdown reading 10:16:12.
If you trade a Carrot evaluation, the number that can end your account is the EQUITY reading, floating P&L included, and the limit that will realistically end it is the DAILY one, not the total. Do not size from the §24 cheatsheet cell: it describes how the limit LEVEL is set, from the balance high-water mark per §07, and misstates what crosses it. Two operational consequences from our own case. First, the Objectives counter on the dashboard is BALANCE-based, so it can read almost untouched while your equity is a few dollars from the floor — watch the chart and the absolute dollar floor, not the counter. Second, a forced close is not guaranteed to land exactly on the floor: ours settled $38.78 below it. The breach itself is OURS and not the firm's — no stop loss was set and 5x of notional was carried overnight, the engine enforced a published rule correctly, and the interface showed the floor in absolute dollars on screen the whole time. Nothing here is scored against Carrot and the score does not move: 73.2/100, grid of 10 September 2026. Recorded in figures and without adjectives: the post-breach screen reads Challenge Failed, then offers 15% OFF a new challenge behind a countdown reading 10:16:12.
Two of our Carrot findings retracted the same evening — score deliberately held at 73.2
This entry retracts part of the two entries below it. They stay published, because this file does not rewrite its own history; read them knowing the corrections here supersede them. Before publishing two open questions about Carrot Funding, we put them to the firm. It answered the same evening and both of our findings were wrong. FIRST, THE VAULT. We had written that rulebook §19 promises an on-chain vault and that we could not locate it, and we published the formula 'the payouts are verifiable, the reserve is not' across the site. That was a reading failure: Carrot's GitBook documentation publishes a complete address table with named roles — Vault Custody Contract, Vault Integrations, a 2-of-4 payout approval multisig and the payout executor EOA — and we had not opened that page. Having opened it we checked it: the Vault Custody Contract on HyperEVM is a Safe holding roughly $15,016 in the Felix/Morpho USDC vault plus $98 on HyperCore. We were then about to publish that figure against the $788,521 of 'funding capital' shown on their Analytics page as a solvency gap. The firm's answer removes that framing entirely: funding capital is an internal risk metric — the capital still free before they stop accepting new funded traders — and not a reserve balance at all. Two different quantities; there is no gap. They add that funds are mid-migration from Arbitrum to HyperEVM, which is why the on-chain picture is partial. The address from which the four verified payouts leave is documented by them as a distribution EOA, so our description of it as an empty wallet holding 607.05 USDC against a large claim was unfair and has been removed everywhere. SECOND, THE NFT. We found no token #3955 in the Funded Bunny Initiative contract on Arbitrum — 551 tokens, IDs 0 to 550 — and were ready to publish that a challenge bought that day mints nothing. The firm answered that tokens are minted on-chain but that the token ID does not equal the challenge ID, because the product was not NFT-native at the start. That checks out: our challenge #3955 is token #550, minted on Arbitrum at 05:00:25 UTC on 10 September 2026, the hour of our purchase, with exactly one Transfer event since — the mint itself. What survives is narrower and still real: §20 and the FAQ both state that every challenge is minted as its own NFT, the mapping between challenge and token is documented nowhere, and the firm told us that clarifying it 'wasn't our priority'. That is a documentation defect confirmed by the source, not an absent product. WHY THE SCORE DOES NOT MOVE. Separately these pull in opposite directions — rules should fall, because a headline claim in §20 and the FAQ does not describe what the contract actually does, and survival should rise, because our reserve criticism was a reading error rather than a finding. Net movement is roughly a tenth of a point. A fourth revision of the same firm in a single day, for 0.1, would cost this grid more credibility than the precision would buy. The facts are corrected on every page today; the score waits for the next real input. TWO DATED COMMITMENTS, RECORDED AND NOT SCORED: on 10 September 2026 Carrot stated it will remove AI tooling from the §23 ban, and that it previously ran up to 200x leverage on gTrade and intends to raise leverage on Hyperliquid once comfortable. Neither is shipped. This grid has never scored a promise; freedom stays at 66 until the rulebook itself changes.
Carrot rules 72 → 78 (total 71.7 → 73.2) — we tested the contradiction instead of publishing it
Earlier the same day we marked Carrot's rules criterion down on one charge: that its rulebook contradicts itself on whether floating P&L can breach you, leaving a reader unable to compute their own drawdown. Rather than leave that standing, we tested it on the paid account. Roya opened two BTC/USD positions and we read the live dashboard against them. Balance and equity are tracked as separate live values — 4,986.169 and 5,054.693, the 68.52 gap being the floating P&L — and the dashboard chart plots EQUITY in the same coordinate space as the two limit lines it draws at 4,750 for the daily loss and 4,500 for the maximum drawdown. The app shows you visually which of the two numbers is measured against the floor. The public FAQ then says it in words, before purchase and without a login: drawdown limits are calculated on equity and not balance, open losing trades count toward the limits in real time, and a breach fires the moment equity touches a limit even temporarily. Three sources agree — §05, the FAQ, and the app's own chart. Exactly one line disagrees, the §24 cheatsheet cell reading 'Balance-based (does not include floating P&L)', and that cell is describing how the limit LEVEL is set, from the balance high-water mark per §07, while misstating what crosses it. That is a drafting defect in a summary table, not a hidden trap, and we priced it as a trap. We also under-rated the interface itself: it publishes the limits as absolute dollars rather than percentages to interpret — 'Max loss: $4,500.00', 'High watermark: $5,000.00', 'Max daily loss: $4,750.00' — with a countdown to the UTC reset. Nothing to compute is the top of this criterion, not the bottom. Why the upgrade stops at 78: the test produced four new defects. The FAQ puts Maximum Loss at 10% from the high-water mark with no 1-Phase exception, against 8% in §03 and §24, so the contradiction moved rather than disappeared. The FAQ's forbidden-practice list adds copy trading and hedge trading, neither of which appears in §23 — two documents, two lists. The dashboard carries a 'verified by OASIS' badge while the FAQ describes the firm as still integrating ROFL, the same present-tense overstatement of an unfinished feature we docked HyperPNL for. And on that same screen the chart is equity-based while the Objectives counter is balance-based: it read 'Max loss $13.83 of $500.00', which is 5,000 minus the balance, while equity sat above the starting balance consuming nothing. One thing we could not test and do not claim: what that counter displays while a position floats at a LOSS, which is the case that actually matters. Testing it would mean losing Roya's money on purpose, and we do not trade our accounts to manufacture a data point. It is recorded as unknown, not inferred.
We paid for a 2-Phase $5,000 evaluation on 10 September 2026 with our own money ($65 list, $52 with royaref, USDC on Arbitrum) and traded it the same day. `tested` goes to true. The 85-point desk cap was never binding at 72.9, so nothing below comes from lifting a ceiling. Start with our error, because it is the largest single correction in this revision. Our 5 September sheet published the 1-Phase $5,000 at $65 with a 5% daily loss and a 10% maximum loss, and documented no consistency rule at all. The configurator shown before payment, and rulebook §03 which is public and requires no login, both read $75, 4% daily, 8% maximum, and a Best Day Rule of 50%. We had copied the 2-Phase row onto the 1-Phase line and missed an entire rule. We also wrote that the fee is the same per account size whatever the structure; it is not — 1-Phase $5K is $75 against $65 for the 2-Phase. Carrot published all of this correctly and in the open. The mistake is ours, it is corrected in public rather than edited away, and it does not mark the firm down. (1) Rules 65 → 72. Three independent sources now agree line by line: the pre-payment configurator, the public rulebook, and the objectives actually applied to our live account — $250 profit target, $250 daily loss, $500 maximum loss on a $5,000 2-Phase. That is precisely the consistency whose absence cost HyperPNL points, and it earns some here. Carrot also discloses outright that it routes orders A-book or B-book at its own discretion (§22) and labels every trader on their own dashboard, a disclosure most firms in this table simply decline to make. What holds the upgrade at 72 is that the rulebook contradicts itself on the one number that decides whether you survive: §05 states equity limits apply to "both realized and unrealized losses", while the §24 cheatsheet states Max Loss is "Balance-based (does not include floating P&L)". §15 says Max Loss "stays the same" once funded while the cheatsheet shows it moving from 8% to 10% on the 1-Phase, and the §07 formula box multiplies the starting balance by the max DAILY loss. A reader cannot compute their own drawdown from this text, which is the criterion itself. (2) Payouts unchanged at 82. All four published payout hashes verify on-chain as genuine Arbitrum USDC transfers — 733.22, 384.38, 399.24 and 799.41, the dashboard rounding down — and published hashes that actually settle are not the norm here. We have not requested a payout ourselves, so there is no first-hand fact to move this in either direction, and the reserve question below is a solvency finding rather than a payment one. Same rule the grid has enforced since 12 August and that Roya enforced again on 9 September: measurements move criteria, inferences do not. (3) Survival 68 → 55. The Points page, read 10 September 2026, states 279 traders in total and a weekly prize pool of $69; one $52 purchase placed us third on the weekly board. This is a materially smaller firm than desk research suggested. Separately, §19 promises that 50% of evaluation revenue flows into a vault and that the allocation is "verifiable on-chain" — we could not locate that vault. All four verified payouts leave the same externally-owned address, which carries no contract code, and it held 607.05 USDC against the $788,521 of funding capital published on the Analytics page. A distribution wallet is not a treasury and we do not claim the firm holds $607; the finding is narrower and worse for the Proof-of-Reserves claim than that: the payouts are verifiable, the reserve behind them is not. (4) Freedom 70 → 66. §12 is genuinely permissive on paper — no time limit, no minimum trading days, no stop-loss requirement, no minimum hold, weekend and news trading allowed — and Hyperliquid's central limit order book is real price discovery rather than oracle pricing. But two hard ceilings are now documented that we did not previously have: leverage caps at 5x across every asset class (§14), and §23 forbids "automated software, high-frequency trading systems, AI-driven tools, or mass order entry systems". A firm cannot headline trading freedom and ban automation in the same rulebook; Propr permits bots and APIs and keeps its 95. (5) Value 80 → 82. §17 claims Hyperliquid's own fee schedule with "no markup", and that is an arithmetic claim, so we measured it on two round trips: HYPE/USD cost $4.40 on $9,786.60 of round-trip notional, or 0.04496%, and ETH/USD cost $4.77 on $10,606.40, or 0.04497%, against a 0.045% base taker rate. Two assets, two directions, matching to the fourth decimal — the claim is exact, and this is the only measured fee verification in the table. Also creditable: no monthly, platform or withdrawal fees, an 80% split, a 100 USDC payout floor, and a challenge NFT the holder can transfer to another address. The caveat for readers is the arithmetic consequence rather than a criticism: a flat round trip still costs about 0.09% of notional. Our ETH position opened at 2,475.90, closed at 2,475.45, and finished at −$3.49. Net 72.9 → 71.7: a first-hand pass that confirmed the firm's documentation is accurate and found ours was not, while revealing an operation smaller and more restricted than desk research implied.
The correction is ours, not the firm's: nothing in Carrot's rules moved between 5 and 10 September 2026. If you were sizing a 1-Phase from our sheet, the entry price is $10 to $100 higher than we printed and the room you have is smaller, not larger — 4% a day and 8% overall instead of 5% and 10% — with a 50% Best Day Rule on top, meaning a single day cannot account for more than half your total profit. The same read documents three ceilings we had never published: leverage caps at 5x on every asset class (§14), §23 forbids "automated software, high-frequency trading systems, AI-driven tools, or mass order entry systems" — so bots and APIs are out at Carrot — and §22 states outright that the firm routes each trade A-book or B-book at its own discretion, labelling every trader on their dashboard. Read §03 yourself before paying; it is free to read and it is the document that would settle a dispute.
Nothing changes for a live account today. If you automate, §23 still forbids it and you can still be breached for it; if you need more than 5x, §14 still caps you there. Treat both statements as intentions with a date attached, not as rules you can trade on, and re-read §14 and §23 yourself before assuming either has moved. The one thing the 200x figure does establish is that 5x is a prudential setting the firm chose, not a technical ceiling of its infrastructure.
Propr: we are re-checking the rulebook version references in our own July and August entries
Nothing changes for a live account. What changes is what we are willing to assert: until this check is finished, treat any version number attached to a Propr rule on this site as unverified, and read the published rulebook on Propr's own site. Screenshot the rules the day you pay — a dated capture is the only version history you control.
HyperPNL bought, funded and traded — desk-research cap lifted, 61.8 → 64.5
We paid $42 for a 1-Step Flex $5,000 evaluation, funded it in USDC on Arbitrum and traded it the same day. `tested` goes to true and the 85-point cap comes off. Four criteria move, and the firm ends up higher than it was, because most of what the money established is in its favour. (1) Rules 64 → 68. Two of our own criticisms fell. The 1-Step requires NO minimum profitable days: the counter on the paid account reads 0/0, so the checkout was right to show no such line and our disclosure complaint of that morning was wrong. The app also states its limits as figures a buyer can check rather than percentages to interpret — a $4,850.00 daily floor and a $25 profitable-day trigger on a $5,000 account — and it publishes a real breach post-mortem: our $25,000 demo was closed automatically at 12:18 on 9 September with the cause named in the interface, Daily Loss Limit, at −3.3%. Against that, a new disclosure finding costs it points: the docs name three contracts — Payment Router, Payout Treasury, Data Recorder — publish an address for none of them, and the purchase we traced end to end touched none of them either. The single on-chain event was a deposit into RelayDepository, a third-party bridging contract identified by the string in its own bytecode; the $42 fee was then debited off-chain in HyperPNL's internal ledger. The one field that looks like an on-chain record, labelled Tier, is not an Arbitrum transaction or block. Documenting contracts you never expose is a disclosure failure, and that is what this criterion measures. The rulebook still covers only the 2-Step, and the homepage still sells "No restrictions" over an 18-jurisdiction exclusion list. (2) Payouts UNCHANGED at 60 — and this is the part we got wrong first. The initial version of this revision cut payouts to 45 on the strength of the purchase trace. Roya challenged it the same day: no payout was requested, so no payout evidence exists, so the payouts criterion has nothing new to price. Roya is right, and the objection is the same one this grid has enforced since 12 August — dated verifiable facts move scores, inferences do not. What we traced is the PURCHASE rail, not the PAYOUT rail; that the fee was debited off-chain does not establish how a withdrawal would settle, and we said as much in our own audit note before scoring as though we had said the opposite. The finding was real and it stays published in full — it simply belongs under rules, where disclosure lives, and it has been moved there. Payouts will move when we request one. (3) Survival 58 → 62: the product is real, delivered and enforcing, which a landing page cannot prove. (4) Freedom 70 → 74: 5x asset leverage carrying $24,594 of notional on a $5,000 account, at least 92 instruments on a live Hyperliquid book, no consistency rule, no time limit and no profitable-day requirement — against an order ticket that will not accept a stop-loss while a position is open. (5) Value 58 → 60: execution cost measured at about 0.055% of $60,720 of volume, in line with the advertised 0.045% taker plus spread, so no hidden markup — though a winning trade of +$6.94 still left the account $26.65 down for the day. Still untested and still the whole question: the 80% split and the "instant" payout claim. The account is in Phase 1 and negative.
HyperPNL revised on four criteria after a session inside the product (62.3 → 61.8)
We opened a free demo account on 9 September 2026 and read the checkout, the Performance Guard and the Terms of Use from the inside. Four changes, in both directions. (1) Rules 60 → 64: the homepage-versus-docs contradiction we published on 5 September was our own error — HyperPNL sells two evaluations, 1-Step and 2-Step, and each set of numbers belongs to one of them. Credit also for a named operator (Hyperpnl Ltd., Cayman Islands, reg. CO-425378) and for the docs' explicit "if a rule is not written here, it is not enforced". Held back because the rulebook documents only the 2-Step, and because the 1-Step checkout hides a minimum-profitable-day rule the app then enforces at $125 on a $25K account. (2) Payouts 70 → 60: the Terms of Use subject payout eligibility to "compliance, anti-abuse checks" and guarantee no timing or availability, while the homepage sells "Even we can't reject your payout"; the funded programme is a "Trade Ideas" arrangement in which the trader owns nothing and the firm keeps execution rebates it calls a possible conflict of interest. (3) Freedom 65 → 70: 92 instruments verified live on a real Hyperliquid order book, with Limit / Market / Stop Loss / TP / Reduce-Only and no consistency rule. (4) Value 60 → 58: $215 for a $25K 1-Step is roughly 1.7× Propr's Turbo at the same size, and deposits are USDC-on-Arbitrum only with an instruction to send $1 more than you intend to deposit. Net movement half a point, because the transparency gained and the payout guarantee lost very nearly cancel. Still capped at 85: we have never bought a HyperPNL evaluation.
Which rules govern your account depends on the tab you clicked at checkout, and only one of the two products has a written rulebook. If you buy the 1-Step — the cheaper ticket at every size except $25,000 — the checkout screen is the whole of your documentation. Screenshot that screen the day you pay. No profitable day is required on the 1-Step: the app tracks the metric, it does not impose it.
HyperPNL: our own $42 purchase left no on-chain trace of the firm — observed 9 September 2026
Buying a HyperPNL evaluation puts your fee into a third-party bridge and then into an internal ledger. Nothing about the purchase, the split or the reserve can be verified by a third party, which is the opposite of what the homepage advertises. We score that where it belongs: as a disclosure failure under the rules criterion, and NOT against payouts. The purchase rail is not the payout rail — that a $42 fee settled off-chain establishes nothing about how a withdrawal would be paid — so the payouts sub-score did not move at all on the day the desk-research cap was lifted, and it stays at 60 until we request a withdrawal and have something to measure. An earlier version of that day's revision did cut it to 45 on this trace alone; the objection was raised and accepted the same day, and the sub-score was restored. The honest comparison, since we have been asked for one: at Propr and at Hypernova we have been paid and have reconciled the money on-chain — Hypernova's 80% split to the cent on Arbitrum, and Propr's Payout Distributor a verified contract on Ethereum with published source. At HyperPNL we have not requested a withdrawal at all, and no address is published for any of the three contracts. No payout of ours has been tested — the account is in Phase 1 and negative — so the 80% split and the "instant" claim remain untested rather than disproved.
Hypernova reserve read: $642,953.63
Direct chain read (block 502546138). Reserve wallet net −106,139.997356 USDC in seven days — 106,140.00 to within 0.3 cent, close to round but not to the cent like the 128,000.00 of 31 Aug; vault up $4,523.80. Total down $101,616.20 vs 31 Aug while the homepage lifetime-payouts counter rose $94.5K over the same window — ~$7.1K untraced. Homepage displayed $649.9K (+$6.9K vs chain); the stats page still showed $668,297 with 5 Sep as its latest payout, so it looked stale.
You cannot check today which version governs the account you are about to buy, and the two versions we read in July are not retrievable from the public page. Screenshot the rules the day you pay: a dated capture is the only version history you control. We keep our July reads dated rather than deleting them — they were read at source.
Five dollars is trivial; two prices for one product is not, because the fee schedule is the document that would settle a dispute. Screenshot the checkout total you actually pay, and treat the rulebook figure as the one the firm can point to later.
The correction is ours, not the firm's: what is published today is 80-90%, and the 90% costs extra at purchase rather than being earned over three profitable months. If you were comparing firms on a 95% headline, that number does not exist on Breakout's site today.
Try Propr −30 %: personal code after proof → public code OWNTHEHOUSE
Any switcher can take −30 % on a first challenge immediately. Pages describing the proof-and-email mechanic must be updated.
Hypernova reserve read: $668,336.00
Split not read; stats page total ($668,336 USDC, cold reserve + operational vault), displayed "$668.3K" — not a direct chain read. Down $76,233.83 in five days, against $715,417 of lifetime payouts published the same day; outflow not traced, so the two figures are reported side by side. Homepage counters were unreliable at this read: $671.3K and $536.4K for the same reserve on two loads minutes apart.
Full registry re-verification — all 10 firms re-checked, no status change
Full DNS + HTTP + manual page re-check of the 10 tracked crypto prop firms, closing the gap since the 10 August verification (the daily automated monitoring ran throughout; this entry publishes it). No status change: …
Hypernova payouts 92 → 96 (total 85.7)
Nine payouts taken on our own funded account 28–31 August 2026, the largest reconciled on-chain at exactly 80% to the cent. Remaining gap to the top sits in the rules criterion.
The Hypernova dashboard (app.hypernova.xyz/payouts, account F2, re-read 1 Nov 2026) lists 11 payouts marked Paid, 3,660.86 USDC received, 28 Aug → 1 Sep 2026 — each with its own transaction. All 11 hashes were checked…
Hypernova: 141 perpetual markets become 99 in six days, with no announcement
If your strategy lives on a thin or exotic pair, check the markets page before buying — a listed instrument on 25 August was not guaranteed on 31 August, and the firm did not say which went.
On-chain reading of 31 August 2026, 03:18 UTC: Hypernova's payout reserve stands at $744,569.83 on Arbitrum (vault $27,174.79 + reserve wallet $717,395.03), down $116,947.51 from the 25 August top-up level. The reserv…
Nine payout requests between 28 and 31 Aug 2026 ($102.54 to $699.43 each), every one marked Paid on the dashboard with an Arbiscan transaction. Spot-checked on-chain: the $699.43 request of 31 Aug settled 559.546701 U…
Hypernova reserve read: $744,569.83
Reserve wallet out exactly 128,000.00 USDC — reads like a treasury movement, not payout flow; destination not traced. Homepage displayed $765.5K: a $20.9K display lag, the widest yet.
Propr payouts 84 → 88 (total 86.7)
Propr's transparency dashboard now publishes a verified Payout Distributor proxy contract on Ethereum (0x6e81…7acf24, 3,864 payout txs) — the fact behind the 12 August markdown ('payer is an ordinary wallet') expired, so the markdown moved. Not 92: still no pre-funded reserve to read.
Automation on your own account is now inside the rules — the beta's §14.2 no longer applies. Copy trading is still a closing offence: automate your own strategy, never someone else's signals.
Hypernova reserve topped up to $861,517.34 — up ~$117K on the 17 August reading
On-chain reading of 25 August 2026: Hypernova's payout reserve stands at $861,517.34 on Arbitrum (Vault + reserve wallet), up from $744,562.56 on 17 August — a top-up of roughly $117K. Status unchanged: active. Record…
Hypernova reserve read: $861,517.34
Down $139.5K in a week from the $1.0M level; homepage display ($861.7K) matches the chain to ~$0.2K.
Propr → us: $153.91 — Our own payout, reconciled on-chain to the cent
$192.39 requested, 153.908936 USDC received on 22 Aug 2026 — exactly 80% ($192.39 × 0.80 = $153.91). Sent by Propr's Trader Payout Sender through its verified Payout Distributor contract on Ethereum, tx 0xea78acbf…ca1…
Hypernova reserve read: $1,001,060.62
Top-up: the reserve wallet took in exactly 260,395.00 USDC. The firm announced 'topped up to $1,000,000' — accurate, slightly understated.
Hypernova reserve read: $744,562.56
Reserve wallet unchanged to the cent in two days; all movement in the vault (payouts drain the vault).
Carrot Funding: advertised account ceiling drops from $500K to $100K
The headline number a firm advertises is not a commitment. A quiet 5× reduction of the ceiling is exactly the kind of change this register exists to date.
Correction: Carrot Funding reclassified active — our 10 Aug 'dead' verdict checked the wrong domain
On 10 August we classified Carrot Funding dead because carrotfunding.com 302-redirects to a HugeDomains parking page. That was the wrong domain: the firm brands itself carrotfunding.io and is fully operational there —…
Hypernova re-checked: public launch announced 14 August, reserve read at $746,229.76
Full re-check of Hypernova. On 14 August 2026 its founder announced the public launch: the invite-only beta is over and the checkout is open on app.hypernova.xyz, with pricing published ($120/$275/$365 on the 25K acco…
Hypernova reserve read: $746,229.76
First direct chain read. Homepage counter (~$750.9K, rounded) no longer matches the chain to the cent.
Grid revision after Hypernova's founder challenged it line by line — four changes
(1) Hypernova's desk-research cap lifted: we had bought and traded an account. (2) Payouts: two Hypernova receipts reconciled against the Vault at exactly 80% (28 July) scored above Propr's then-unverifiable ordinary-wallet payer. (3) Propr's rules score marked down for a 20% price rise shipped without announcement (2-Step 100K, $749 → $899). (4) Survival now rewards verifiable on-chain solvency. Net: the two firms one point apart, for opposite reasons.
You can buy a product whose rules are not in the published rulebook. Before paying for Pro or the $200K tier, get the format's exact target/daily/drawdown from the checkout screen and keep a dated screenshot — the rulebook will not settle a dispute it does not mention.
Solana Funded: advertised ceiling halves from $250K to $100K
Same lesson as Carrot: size the account you can actually buy today, not the one in last month's screenshot.
HyperPNL: the $200K tier disappears from the pricing page; $50K and $100K still 'Soon'
The only account you can buy is the $25K. Treat every 'Soon' tier as non-existent for planning.
Full registry re-check: GT Funded reclassified relaunching (unproven), FundedPoly still 402
Second dated pass over all tracked firms. GT Funded: the original gtfunded.com has had no DNS record since June 2026; a new site on gtfunded.xyz is a waitlist landing page whose own figures contradict each other ($250…
Hypernova reserve read: $770,556.00
Figure published on the firm's homepage; taken as the starting point, not a chain read.
Propr: floating P&L no longer counts toward daily loss and max drawdown
An intraday wick against you no longer ends the account; only where you close (and the start-of-day balance) matters. Materially looser for scalpers and anyone holding through news. Until the rulebook is re-versioned, treat it as observed behaviour and re-check the rules page before relying on it.
Propr → us: $119.79 — Our first payout, requested and received
119.79 USDC, settled in 2 minutes on 31 Jul 2026 — the first Propr payout that touched our own wallet.
Hypernova: $7,663.03 — Largest single payout we verified
Announced gross $9,578.79 × 80% split = $7,663.03 — exactly the USDC transfer that left the Vault on 28 Jul 13:19 UTC. Matched to the cent, twice (second: 8,812.44 → 7,049.95).
Propr rulebook v1.0.5: the daily-loss floor added six days earlier is removed
A losing streak compounds: each day's allowance is computed on a smaller balance. Plan the daily limit in dollars from the current balance, not from the account's nominal size.
Registry opened: 10 crypto prop firms under dated DNS/HTTP monitoring
First dated checks recorded for the crypto prop firm status registry: every tracked firm — living ones included — gets DNS resolution, HTTP status and a manual read of the live page, each check dated. GT Funded entere…
FAQ
What is in this changelog?
Every dated assertion this site makes, in one append-only list: 23 grid revisions, 24 rulebook changes, 10 status registers, 19 verified payouts, 10 reserve readings. Each line links to the page that holds the proof — the scoring arithmetic, the before/after rule text, the DNS/HTTP check, the transaction hash, the Arbiscan reading.
Do you ever edit a past entry?
No. A wrong verdict gets a new dated entry that corrects it — the 15 August 2026 Carrot Funding correction is still here with the mistake it fixed. Append-only is what makes a changelog worth citing.
Why publish score revisions?
Because a score that can move down, with the reason written next to it, is the only kind that means anything. The 12 August 2026 revision was triggered by a firm's founder challenging our grid line by line; three of our lines were wrong and one criterion was missing, and the entry says so.
Sources by stream: scoring · rulebook changes · status register (RSS available) · verified payouts · reserve tracker. Data reusable under CC-BY 4.0.